Paul Hammond's Blog: Agile, Software and Life

Paul Hammond's Blog

Moleskine Durability

Thursday, February 07 2008 - Blog

I've been a fan of the Moleskine notebook for a while now.  Used in days gone past by the likes of Hemingway and Picasso, they are described as "notebooks covered in hard-wearing oilcloth-covered cardboard (Moleskine)".  I am not convinced about the hard-wearing bit.

I use a large lined notebook.  It is about A5 sized, and has 240 pages all ready for note taking goodness.  However, I have never made it to the end of a notebook without the cover cracking or splitting in some way.  My latest notebook didn't even last until the middle, as you can see in the first picture below where the black elastic marks my "current page".  The second picture is a close-up of the split along the edge of the spine, and the third is a larger image showing where I crudely patched up the initial cracking with tape.

Moleskine Usage Moleskine Falling Apart Moleskine Falling Apart

Yesterday, I finally had to buy a roll of gaffa tape and replace the shoddy tape with a decent "top to bottom" taped up spine.  It has given the notebook back a spine, but boy does it look ugly!

When I see other people's notebooks, they always look pristine.  Is it just me?  Am I particularly hard on my Moleskines?  I don't feel like I am; I'm not deliberately mistreating them in cruel ways.  I bet Hemingway and Picasso didn't have to gaffa tape THEIR notebooks!

Oh well.  The paper is still great quality and the notebooks sit nice and flat when you open them due to the way they are stitched, so I guess I'll just have to make do with my custom repair work to keep the outsides as good as the insides.

Tagged as:

#1 David Burden on Wednesday, March 05 2008 at 7:58 AM

Like the look of that - I've just placed an order.

#2 packdude on Monday, June 21 2010 at 8:47 PM

No, it's not just you.I'm halfway through my second Moleskine hardcover pocket sized notebook, and I've already had to reinforce it in many places: inside both covers, tape the spine (it's split), and glue inside the spine to help keep the pages from falling out.I carry my notebooks in a backpack, and they do not get abused, only used.I emailed the company about the issue, but they claim that their notebooks "do not have this problem."Based on the numerous hits I received when Googling "Moleskine Durability," and my own experience, I would have to say that Moleskine is more of a marketing engine than a producer of good product.Maybe their new softbound notebooks are better?I will be switching to their "cahier" notebooks as they are bound much better, even if they don't have as many pages in them.Either that, or switching to a different brand that has leather covers, like C.R. Gibson.

#3 Paul Hammond on Thursday, June 24 2010 at 7:07 PM

Thanks for your comment, packdude.I have actually been using a cahier for a little while, and it is fairing much better!Like you, I carry it in my backpack, and use it daily.So far, it is not really wearing at all.Once I have filled this cahier, I am going to try a softbound notebook.We'll see if that is any better.

Leave a Comment